I really like fancy flavored peanut butter and almond butter and all those butters. The problem is they’re usually double or triple the price. Thankfully they’re so easy to make at home. This is a great DIY recipe if you want to make breakfast a little more special, or even a great homemade gift to give a peanut butter lover in your life.
Honey and vanilla go so well together, even better with peanut butter. I got tired of making this in single servings and decided to make a big batch so I could eat it again and again. You can start with peanuts or peanut butter that’s already ground—the recipe’s pretty much the same either way.
Honey Vanilla Peanut Butter
Prep time: 10 minutes
Cook time: 0 minutes
Ingredients(Makes about 16oz):
- 12oz(3 cups) peanuts OR 12oz(1 1/2 cups) peanut butter
- 1/2 Tablespoon good quality vanilla extract
- 3 heaping Tablespoons honey
Method:
- Put the peanuts into the food processor and blend until it forms a smooth, runny butter(if using peanut butter, omit this step).
- Combine the rest of the ingredients with the peanut butter in the food processor and blend until emulsified.
- Scrape into a seal-tight jar. Store at room temperature for up to a month.
I somewhat wanted to add more honey to this because it wasn’t quite sweet enough for my taste; then again, I have a huge sweet tooth and would turn everything into dessert if I could, so I’m guessing 3 tablespoons is enough for most people, although judge by taste always.
You aren’t kidding about the price – they’re super expensive! My fave was a limited edition vanilla cranberry peanut butter from Target…it’s probably good for my budget that they don’t make it any more.
They don’t make that anymore?! I loved that stuff!
Yum! I’m going to try this with cashew butter!
where’s my spoon so I can dig into this. Why bother with an english muffin or anything else…just a spoon is sufficient 🙂
Love this!! I actually have a secret santa gift I have to get that I had no idea what to buy–and I think this might be perfect 😀 Thanks for the great recipe!
What a great idea! The “fancy” nut butters are so expensive.
That vanilla bean paste rocks my face off regularly.
I’m with Averie, except forget the spoon. My finger is going in this baby!
I recently made maple vanilla almond butter for a friend’s birthday and, by god, it was hard to give it to her in the end. I think I’ll have to make this with no other reason than to eat it all myself
Mmmmm, this looks good! Perfect for a sandwich!
MMMMMMM.
As another tip (for my New Englanders) a lot of Job Lots carry the PB&Co ones. YUM.
I love shopping there. They also have a lot of Bob’s Red Mill items
I remember going through my teenage rebellion phase and HATING it because I thought I was too cool for it…then I became a poor college student…and then a vegetarian…and then a entry level worker…and now a clean eater. Thus, Job Lot became my heaven. They just “re-opened” near me and the store is massive, wallet sucking, and amazing!
[…] Honey Vanilla Peanut Butter from The Wannabe Chef […]