Ketchup is the most perfect food. It’s sweet; it’s salty; it’s tangy; it’s savory; it’s delicious. Some days I choose a meal based on if I can add ketchup to it. Who doesn’t do that?
I’ve been wanting to make my own ketchup for a while and finally got around to it after months of putting it off. I figured since I waited this long I wouldn’t make just ordinary ketchup; instead I’d go for something with a defined flavor and a kick. The maple syrup in this adds a little more depth to the taste and the cayenne definitely hits you in the end. Ketchup becomes a staple food in the Summer so I have no doubt I’ll be making more of this to slather on whatever’s being grilled.
Maple Cayenne Ketchup
Ingredients(Makes a little over 2 cups):
- 56oz tomato puree*
- 1/2 cup maple syrup
- 1/4 cup white vinegar
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1/2 teaspoon cayenne pepper
- 1/4 teaspoon paprika
*If you can’t find tomato puree, look for whole skinned tomatoes and puree them yourself using a food processor or high-powered blender.
Combine all of the ingredients together in a large pot and mix. Cook over medium heat for 60 minutes stirring occasionally until the puree reaches a thick consistency.
Store in a sealed container in the refrigerator for 2-4 weeks.
Obviously I had to make a scrambled egg breakfast sandwich with chickpea flour crepes the next morning to try it out. This ketchup is spot on, ya’ll. It doesn’t look quite as smooth as store-bought ketchup but their flavor can’t compete.
LOVE the kick you gave to the ketchup!
just drooled on my keyboard. might have to take this thing to IT to get fixed now. just kidding. awesome recipe!
Really cool flavor combo, I bet it’s amazing!
this is my perfect recipe.
condiment + ketchup + maple + no garlic/onions/salt in any amount other than trace salt.
thank you!
This looks really great, Evan. I’m grilling some portobello mushrooms this weekend and, can’t lie, I want ketchup on ’em. This may class it up…a bit 😉
This sounds wonderful. I often find that Heinz ketchup, as terrific as it is, is too sweet. I love the idea of maple syrup in lieu of high fructose corn syrup.
Oh yum. The Dude made fun of me yesterday because I put ketchup on eggs (he’s a Communist). I feel like he would think I’m much classier with this fancy version.
Umm, eggs + ketchup are like half of my meals, the other half being eggs + maple syrup #imsoclassy
Great unique spin on homemade ketchup!
I’m so jealous of your breakfast sandwich. I’m obsessed with ketchup, it’s my go to condiment.
Can this be eaten as a soup? Cause that’s how I roll.
I was never a ketchup gal but this has changed my mind! Just found your blog and have been looking to incorporate more gluten free into my meals. Great blog!
This is interesting. I need to experiment more with flavored ketchup. I’ve made a harissa ketchup and a sriracha ketchup; however, neither were from scratch. Thanks for sharing!
I’ve made my own mango ketchup before, but this sounds even more amazing!
I have also been meaning to make my own ketchup! I think I’ll make your recipe this weekend, it looks so good!
this looks SO GOOD.
Ooooh this sounds amazing! I love it!
I love the idea of spicy and sweet ketchup! Ketchup on eggs? You’d get along great with my brother :).