I love peppermint patties. What’s not to love? Their chocolaty and sweet and it feels like you’ve just brushed your teeth after you eat one. My grandparents always kept the miniature knock-off versions from CVS called “thin mints” at their apartment and I could eat a sleeve a day. There’s nothing more satisfying than a big, whole peppermint patty, except maybe one that you’ve made yourself.
I’ve had these on my to-make list ever since seeing this post on Megan’s blog. I kept putting them off not knowing how utterly easy these are to make. I made them New Year’s Eve morning and they were gone before the clock struck midnight. They’re naturally vegan and gluten-free, so if you’re cooking for allergies and want to avoid any specialty ingredients, go with these for an easy crowd pleaser.
Homemade Peppermint Patties
Ingredients(Makes 24 patties):
- 2 1/4 cup powdered sugar, sifted
- 1 1/2 Tablespoons agave nectar(or any liquid sweetener)
- 1 1/2 Tablespoons water
- 1 Tablespoon coconut oil, softened or melted
- 1 teaspoon peppermint extract
- 1 bag(12oz) bittersweet or semisweet chocolate chips
In a large bowl, mix the powdered sugar, agave nectar, coconut oil, peppermint extract, and water. Continue mixing with your hands even if it doesn’t look like there’s enough moisture there; eventually it will all come together and form a dough ball.
Take off chunks of filling from the dough ball and roll them into 3/4-inch balls. Press the balls down in between your hands and form patties. Lay these out on a baking tray and refrigerate or freeze for 30 minutes until firm
When the patties are ready, melt down the chocolate in a microwave or over a double-boiler. Line a baking tray with parchment paper to set the peppermint patties to dry once coated.
To coat, lay the patty down on top of the melted chocolate. Immediately flip it over with a fork and lift it out of the chocolate from the bottom. Wipe off any excess chocolate from the bottom and lay it on the lined baking tray.
Let the patties sit at room temperature for an hour or refrigerate for 10 minutes before removing them from the paper.
I’m a sucker for any popular “junk food” dessert made homemade. I think they’re SO impressive. I wouldn’t worry if your patties aren’t all the same size or the chocolate isn’t smooth; those kind difference make these distinctively homemade.
These are great to eat after dinner to freshen your breath, if you don’t just eat a handful for dinner that is.
Though I love covering everything in chocolate, the filling looks good enough to eat on its own. Yum.
this is one of your finest ideas. ever! i love peppermint patties :0 i think i have all the ingedients too!
Someone at my office made these before Christmas. They were SO good I ate like 4 of them.
Mmmmmm
oh my gosh.
(that is all)
Oooh, these look so good!
I have to try making these. Peppermint patties are amazing.
And I completely agree–homemade junk foods are the best! I made homemade Reese’s cups before and they were mind blowing! 🙂
My mom would go crazy for these. I’m going to have to give them a try! Thanks Evan!
Mint and chocolate are perfect together – I polished off a box of dark chocolate peppermint patties from my stocking in 2 days…maybe it’s time to make my own 😉
Evan those look delish! I know Jenna ELR recently did some that look alot like yours and a girl did a guest post on my site about 14 mos ago for a peppermint patty but it’s a different “middle” than what you and Jenna did. I hadnt seen Megan’s post…but wow, they look sooo good!
you can come make me some peppermint patties anytime 🙂
Omg I love peppermint patties… now I can make them at home?! *DIES* 😛
ooooomyg. evan. i want these.
These are one of my favorite candies!
Thanks for the reminder that homemade junkfood is always appealing. I’m always trying to make no/low-sugar versions of things for various reasons (and you can make a great low-sugar peppermint patty using coconut butter, btw) and chocolate/mint is the most irresistible combination. But when I’ve made peanut butter cups and fudge, etc, it’s always gone over very well even made with all the junk ingredients (except for those I simply refuse to use)!
You have no idea how excited I am about these. I love homemade candy substitutes – I’ve done peanut butter cups and butterfinger, now I must add peppermint paddies to the mix. Thank you so much for the recipe (and I love that these are easily vegan! Woot!)
Wow, these look delicious! I am a huge fan of homemade “junk” food. I’ve made homemade PB cups before, now I have to try these!
Thanks for your comment on my blog.
My sister would love these peppermint patties! You’re right about the “clean teeth” feeling. I think that’s why my mother serves them alongside dessert at her dinner parties.
YUM! I love homemade candy. It’s so much better than factory-made. These look awesome!
Thanks for your comment!
I love learning how to make things homemade. Usually it means finding out how easy they are to create. I love that you made peppermint patties! Yum 🙂
Are you for serious?
These look a-mazing. I’d like some right now please. 🙂
I adore the combination of mint and chocolate! Sounds much better than the store bought mint patties too
YUM These are my favorite candies (besides Reece’s PB cups, of course).
Love these!
i had NO idea these were that easy! however, if i do make them, i feel like i will rationalize having constant bad breath just to eat the whole batch of these…
Brilliant! These look awesome, and I absolutely love that they’re vegan. My sister and I used to get a large peppermint patty in our Christmas stockings every year, and we loved ’em (and then, who doesn’t love the Thin Mint Girl Scout cookies?!)
Thanks for sharing 🙂
I’ve also been wanting to try and make these but thought it would too time consuming. You make it look so easy.
How did I miss this?! I have a feeling this might be the recipe to defeat my peppermint essence aversion, which started when I poured too much of it into a turned-out-sludgy “candy cane rice pudding”…
Peppermint patties have been on my to make list for an eternity.. They looks SO good!!
wow. i so saved this recipe for the next time i need to impress dinner guests.
Hey, I stumbled upon your site recently – great recipes! I just made these tonight (using honey instead of agave – I didn’t have any on hand), and they’re all kinds of awesome.
Thanks! I love them, too. I’m just fishing for an excuse to make them again.
Good god!
Crap! I’m home today, left with the ingredients for Peppermint Patties. I need to make these, there my favorite candy! I can’t wait to try this!!
[…] Pinterest link above is the exact recipe I used. I didn’t do anything differently. Click here and read it directly from the […]
[…] Homemade peppermint patties(vegan + gluten-free) […]